Social Democrats accuse Taoiseach of ‘dismiss, deflect, repeat’ amid CUH row

Taoiseach Micheál Martin speaks at an EU Council meetingplaceholder image
Taoiseach Micheál Martin speaks at an EU Council meeting

Opposition TDs said the Government needs to take responsibility for not resolving a row over patient safety concerns in Cork University Hospital.

Patients in the Taoiseach’s own constituency are “paying the price” for him failing to resolve a row around patient safety in Cork University Hospital (CUH), according to the opposition.

In August, CUH chief executive Jennifer Kearney wrote a letter to the Government warning that it would not be safe going into winter, with a shortfall of about 1,000 staff.

The letter, which was sent to Micheál Martin, called for an urgent approval of 172 priority posts and for the staffing of 21 acute beds.

Since then, a row has played out in the media and Houses of the Oireachtas, between CUH staff and Health Service Executive (HSE) leaders, and opposition parties and government ministers.

placeholder image

Appearing before the Health Committee on Wednesday morning, HSE chief executive officer Anne O’Connor said: “As a hospital, CUH is not unique in facing huge service pressures. But it is unique in that it appears to be conducting its management business via the media with extraordinary regularity.”

Asked if she had spoken to the CUH chief executive, she replied, “no, not recently”.

Speaking later at Leaders’ Questions in the Dáil, Social Democrats TD Cian O’Callaghan said it is unbelievable that Ms O’Connor would criticise CUH management for speaking to the media without contacting them herself.

“On the one hand, the head of the HSE is on the airwaves attacking CUH for raising serious issues in the media, and at the same time the head of the HSE doesn’t even talk directly to CUH,” he said.

“It takes a lot longer, Taoiseach, to drive to RTÉ than it takes to pick up the phone. It is an absolutely remarkable admission.

“Staff at CUH are begging for help but the response from the HSE is essentially ‘get back in your box’. It’s a classic case of shoot the messenger, in order to deflect from the serious concerns about patient safety and to deter staff in other hospitals from speaking out.”

On Wednesday, 59 patients were waiting for beds at CUH, the highest number in the country, 52 of them waiting on trolleys and seven on wards.

Mr O’Callaghan also claimed the Government has to take responsibility for its failure to address the crisis.

placeholder image

He said: “Taoiseach, your Government is up to its neck in this.

“You refuse to take any responsibility. You point to increased funding and staffing, and yet you totally ignore the fact that a 2024 report found that CUH had the lowest rate of workforce growth of any acute hospital in the country while it also has the biggest bed deficit in Ireland.

“Taoiseach, it is patients in your own constituency, in Munster and South Leinster, who are paying the price for your failure to address this crisis.

“We know that cancer surgeries have already been cancelled, new trauma bays are gathering dust and CT scanners are out of action for extended periods. What will it take before you take action?”

The results of an independent review of CUH by the Health Information and Quality Authority (HIQA) are due to be delivered to the Government in the coming weeks.

Mr Martin said any Government interjection must be based on a systematic approach.

“First of all, deputy, I reject your assertions,” he said.

“We have to have a systemic basis of defining and understanding that, because that’s a very significant issue. So, people took that very seriously when issues were raised around patient safety, and so that’s to be systemic.

“What do I mean by that? I mean HIQA has to be involved. I mean the National Patient Safety Office. It just can’t be you or I or others saying ‘I put my hand up’.

placeholder image

“I may say there’s a safety issue. There has to be a systemic basis. Has to be standards and metrics that govern whether there is a safety risk or not.”

Mr O’Callaghan said the Taoiseach is dismissing the concerns that CUH staff have for their patients.

“Dismiss, deflect, repeat. That’s what you keep on doing,” he said.

“Now, the staff, the doctors, the management in CUH, they have raised serious issues of patient safety and you’re just dismissing those out of hand as if the staff working there in the hospital don’t know what they’re talking about.”

The Taoiseach responded: “I have dismissed nothing. Just because you say I have dismissed, deflect doesn’t mean it’s the truth. You just had a sort of rehearsed line and you just repeated it. You didn’t listen to me at all. You didn’t listen at all to what I said.”

Earlier in the week, it emerged that CUH staff were worried about attending management meetings for fears they were being recorded without their knowledge.

While the Taoiseach said on Monday that this “concerned” him, he also said issues in CUH are “not going to be sorted by megaphone engagement”.

Speaking at Leaders’ Questions on Wednesday, Labour leader Ivana Bacik accused Mr Martin of waffling.

placeholder image

“Jennifer Kearney did what should be expected of any healthcare worker, she saw vulnerable sick people’s health and lives being put at risk, and she spoke up for them, truly as a canary in the coal mine,” she said.

“But far from heeding her warnings, official Ireland has pilloried her. The Minister for Health called her requests for help unrealistic. Taoiseach, you alluded to Ms Kearney engaging what you termed megaphone engagement.

“This begs the question, does the Government want to silence those who speak out about failings in the health service? Because the debacle has already had a chilling effect.

“I have seen that myself. Her representations have been made to my office by people flagging systemic failings in hospitals, dangerous overcrowding, people missing out on care because of staff shortages.”

In a heated Dáil chamber, the Taoiseach began his reply by describing as “outrageous” interruptions from opposition TDs.

He defended Government spending on CUH and said reform is needed in Ireland’s health service.

“I’m not pillorying anybody. I have no issue. My only issue is to resolve the issues that have been identified,” he said.

“But the other point is, it’s not credible either to say that there has been no investment in CUH. Like, the staff has gone up by 49.8%, 50%, from about 3,467 in 2020 to 5,194 today. That’s a 1,700 increase since the 1st of January in staff.

“Reform is critical because the health budget has gone up exponentially by any yardstick. There are big issues facing us and that will become progressively more acute as a financing issue. So, reform has to be a core part of what we’re about, and that is important.”

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice