Tánaiste says ‘definitively no’ to Government TDs breaking whip on triple lock

Irish Cabinet meetingplaceholder image
Irish Cabinet meeting

Ten Fianna Fáil TDs are supporting an amendment to the bill to reform the system around the deployment of Irish peacekeeping troops.

The Tánaiste Simon Harris said he would not consider allowing members of the Government to vote freely in the Dáil on the reform of the triple lock system, despite several TDs seeking amendments to the Bill.

A Bill to reform the system around the deployment of peacekeeping troops was voted in by a small margin in the Dáil last month.

The legislation, which the Government aims to have enacted by the end of the year, would reform the triple lock system currently in play, which dictates that UN approval, a decision by Government and a vote in the Dáil are all required before the deployment of more than 12 members of the Irish Defence Forces.

placeholder image

The Government Bill seeks to remove any UN mandate from the legislation.

Ten Fianna Fáil TDs are supporting an amendment to the bill, put forward by Limerick TD Willie O’Dea, which would require the Defence Minister of the time to explain to the UN general assembly why the deployment troops would tie in with a specific resolution of the assembly.

The Tánaiste was asked, given that Government TDs have differing views on the Bill, if they should be allowed to break the government whip.

He responded: “I just say on that, definitively no.”

He said that reform of the triple lock system was in the Programme for Government, which was ratified by every member of the two parties in power, Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael, and supporting independents.

“It is a programme for government, and every Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil and independent TD who support the Government ratified the programme for government, as did our members,” he said.

“So there is no member of the Fine Gael Parliamentary Party, nor respectively of the Fianna Fáil Parliamentary Party, who didn’t vote in favour, at least I presume they all voted in favour of the Programme for Government.

“So this idea didn’t fall from the sky. It’s not a new idea. In fact, it was the leader of Fianna Fáil, the Taoiseach, who would have initiated, very much, work on this in his time as minister of defence with the Commission on the Future Defence.

“We certainly made our views clear on it, and I certainly made my views clear on it during the election too. So it’s no surprise to anybody in Government or outside government that this is a piece of legislation that we’re going to progress, and because it’s a matter of the Programme for Government, as we’re all very clearly about, certainly that’s my strong view.”

The Government and opposition have been locked in a row since the triple lock Bill was passed, with the opposition arguing that removing the piece of legislation would erode Ireland’s position as a neutral country.

placeholder image

Sinn Féin staged a protest outside Government Buildings last month and has consistently said any reform must first go to a referendum.

On Wednesday, a Sinn Féin motion to that effect was defeated by the Government by 84 votes to 77, but notably, Independent TD Barry Heneghan, who supports the Government in key votes voted with Sinn Féin.

In a statement after the vote, he said: “As an Independent TD, I signed up to support a Programme for Government that committed to “reforming” the triple lock while protecting Ireland’s active military neutrality.

“Reform does not automatically mean removal.”

Defence Minister Helen McEntee said that supporters of a referendum are being misled by the opposition.

“This is people playing politics. The opposition are saying put it to a referendum. Not a single person in opposition has said what they would put to a referendum,” she said.

“They have to be honest with people, and they are not being honest with people. They are also continuing to repeat a lie and a falsehood. They are saying that we will send our troops to fight with the Israeli Defence Forces.

“Senior members in Lebanon have said that they are putting our soldiers at risk by repeating these lies, and I would ask them to not play politics with something that is a really serious matter.”

On Saturday, a demonstration will take place in the Garden of Remembrance in Dublin, called ‘Save our Neutrality – Hands off the Triple Lock’.

The group organising the rally said they will “send a message to Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael that the people of Ireland in overwhelming majority want us to keep our proud anti-imperialist tradition of neutrality”, as they call for a referendum.

placeholder image

Ms McEntee said that a referendum is to amend the constitution, to take something out of the constitution, or to put something in.

She said that those attending the rally need to realise that there is already an article in the Irish constitution that states “very clearly, if the EU wants to form a neutral defence alliance, it cannot happen without the say so of our state”.

“To anybody thinking of going to that rally, I would ask them, what are they proposing to have a constitution and a referendum on,” she said.

“We’re not putting anything into the constitution. We’re not taking anything out. What is it that they want to amend?

“Because what we have already in the constitution is very clearly that our neutrality is protected, and if we want to change that, that we would have to have a referendum, and we are not planning to do that.”

People Before Profit TD Paul Murphy encouraged people to attend Saturday’s rally. He said that there is not much time left to save the triple lock.

“We have little more than two weeks left to save the triple lock. If the Government succeeds in abolishing it, then we will soon see Irish soldiers being deployed on missions abroad without any regard to the United Nations or to international law,” he said.

placeholder image

“The sole purpose of the triple lock is to codify international law, that says it is only legitimate peacekeeping if the mission is endorsed by the UN Security Council or the UN General Assembly, into our national law.

“Without that UN guardrail, the Government can send Irish troops wherever they decide, with whatever lethal ‘coalition of the willing’ is constructed to pursue Western imperial interests. If we end the triple lock, the only legal obstacle to that, then that’s what Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael will do.

“Despite years of Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil propaganda campaigns to undermine neutrality, public opinion remains firmly in favour of the triple lock and neutrality.

“But now we are at the decisive point, and we urge the public to turn out in their thousands tomorrow to say to the Government – hands off the triple lock.”

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice