15 Aug 2022

Garda takes Google to court over 'defamatory' Youtube video

garda goole youtube

Garda takes google to court.

A Garda has brought a High Court action aimed at compelling internet giants Google to take down a Youtube video with a commentary which he claims is false, malicious and is defamatory of him.

The Garda, who can't be identified for legal reasons says he features in a Youtube video, more than 3 minutes long, which was taken at a public order incident in 2016 when he and other members affect an arrest. 

He says in the commentary on the video he is wrongly accused of kicking a minor in the head. The audio on the clip not match and does not reflect the images displayed in the video, he claims.  

The commentary on the video also wrongly accuses the Garda of having "assaulted that young fella," that he is "after kickin' the head off him"  and the Garda has been " boot'n him."

The statements on the video the Garda says are unfounded and without substance, and the video has impacted on him as an individual and a member of An Garda Siochana. 

The Garda instructed by Ken Fogarty SC and John Morrissey Bl, instructed by solicitor Damien Sheridan was informed of the video by several of his colleagues after it was posted. 

He says it received almost 40,000 views and the website had dozens of comments. 

The Garda's solicitors attempted to make contact with the person who posted the video clip on Youtube calling for it to be taken down. 

However, Mr Sheridan was unable to determine the identity of the poster is or what that person's address is. 

Mr Sheridan then wrote to Youtube, which is owned by Google, demanding the video be taken down. 

When the video remained published on the website the Garda initiated High Court proceedings against the internet firms. 

In his proceedings, the Dublin based Garda seeks various order including an injunction restraining Youtube LLC and Google Ireland Ltd from refusing to remove the video from Youtube with immediate effect. 

He also seeks orders directing the defendants to deliver the identity of the person who posted the video, and all other relevant contact information and details within its power and control. 

The Garda further seeks an injunction prohibiting the defendants from allowing any further postings by the person who put up the allegedly defamatory video on Youtube or other websites within their control. 

The Garda previously obtained a temporary High Court orders directing that the video be taken down, which were replaced by an undertaking in the same terms by the defendants

 However, the Garda's lawyers have claimed that it is still technically possible to view the video. 

The matter returned before the High Court when a number of pre-trial motions in the case commenced before Mr Justice Tony O'Connor.  

The motions relate to whether the Irish Courts have the jurisdiction to make the orders sought by the Garda and if the defendants were properly served with the injunction proceedings.

The Judge adjourned the motions to allow the sides to prepare further legal submissions to a date in January.

To continue reading this article for FREE,
please kindly register and/or log in.

Registration is absolutely 100% FREE and will help us personalise your experience on our sites. You can also sign up to our carefully curated newsletter(s) to keep up to date with your latest local news!

Register / Login

Buy the e-paper of the Donegal Democrat, Donegal People's Press, Donegal Post and Inish Times here for instant access to Donegal's premier news titles.

Keep up with the latest news from Donegal with our daily newsletter featuring the most important stories of the day delivered to your inbox every evening at 5pm.