Portlaoise Crimecall pub assault soldier avoids conviction


CCTV footage captured the Defence Forces member assaulting the man in Kavanagh’s Bar in Portlaoise
A member of the Defence Forces who was featured on RTÉ’s Crimecall assaulting a man in a Portlaoise pub has escaped conviction.
Barry Galvin (44) of 54 Willow Park, Carlow, was found guilty of assault causing harm at Kavanagh’s pub, Main Street, Portlaoise on October 8, 2023 following an earlier hearing.
He appeared before the court again, where Judge Andrew Gubbins viewed a probation report, victim impact statement and a restorative justice report. He noted the case had gone to a full contested hearing and the man had no previous convictions.
Solicitor Tim Kennelly said his client had been contacted by a friend to tell him that he appeared on Crimecall.
He said on hearing that he had appeared on RTÉ, his client took copious amounts of alcohol and jumped into the River Barrow and was hospitalised as a result.
He said the man had served in the Defence Forces for 26 years having left school after doing his junior certificate.
Mr Kennelly said on the night of the assault his client had gone out for a meal with his partner before attending the pub. When there, he said the injured party had approached him on a couple of occasions before the assault occurred. He said the man was “deeply remorseful” after the incident.
He explained that the man had suffered “bouts of addiction” and had a very difficult childhood. He said his client’s father had been violent, abused alcohol and regularly beat his mother, culminating in an incident where he slit his mother’s throat.
She survived the attack and his father was given five years in prison. When he got out of prison his father struck up a relationship with another woman. This woman was also subject to abuse and she killed his father and was later acquitted of his murder.
“This is his one and only skirmish with the law,” said Mr Kennelly. “What we have, Judge, is what appears to be an anomaly,” he said.
Mr Kennelly said his client had contributed to society through his 26 years of service in the Defence Forces.
“If he is convicted here today he will lose the 26 years of service that he has given this country,” he said.
Mr Kennelly acknowledged that there is a victim in the case and he said he was not asking the judge to “wave a magic wand” in relation to the matter. “He has brought with him a sum of €4,500,” said Mr Kennelly.
He said the man has engaged with probation, undergone treatment, been “clean and sober” for two years and he was deemed by the Probation Service to be an individual who is at low risk of reoffending.
Mr Kennelly said his client had “put the cart before the horse” when he went and got treatment without any instruction from the courts. He said there should be no concern about allowing the man back into society.
“Are you saying that if he were to receive a conviction it would be the end of his career?” asked Judge Gubbins.
Mr Kennelly said his understanding was that if he was convicted and received a fine greater than a week’s salary he would be dismissed but even a conviction without a fine could potentially lead to him losing his job.
He said his client had made a “monumental mistake” but he asked that he be given one chance.
“Mr Galvin comes before the court having been convicted of Section 3 assault which is a very serious offence,” said Judge Gubbins.
In the Circuit Court the offence can attract a sentence of up to ten years in prison, he said.
He noted the injured party had “lost consciousness and began to vomit as a result of the blows he received to the head”.
He said the man had suffered bruising to the scalp and had discharged himself from hospital. The assault impacted his relationship as he was unwilling to go out socially for weeks afterwards. The victim was also waking up with nightmares for weeks following the assault.
“He indicates that he has never gone through trauma like that before,” Judge Gubbins noted.
He said the case was contested so the man can not get any credit as would happen in the case of a plea.
Judge Gubbins noted the man was of the view that the injured party had been looking for trouble.
“He should have asked a member of security to intervene,” he said.
The fact that he is in the Defence Forces is an aggravating factor because he “possesses a certain set of skills that ordinary members of the public don’t have”.
However, the judge highlighted matters to consider. He said Gubbins said the man had undergone treatment, engaged with restorative justice, had no previous convictions and had brought clear drug screenings to court.
Judge Gubbins also noted the man was accepting responsibility and had brought €4,500 to court as compensation. He said if he recorded a conviction it would jeopardise the defendant’s career.
“Seldom has the court come across someone who has as much mitigation,” said the Judge.
In what he said was a “major departure for the court,” Judge Gubbins invoked Section 1 (1) of the Probation Act.
He said that, with everything that was outlined in court the offending appeared to be an aberration and he said the man deserved a chance given the manner in which he had met the case. The €4,500 was handed over to the victim before the court sitting concluded.
