Laois family asked DPP not to prosecute neighbours after tragic farm death

placeholder image
Laois Live

Father and son fined €100,000 after farmer fell while working on roof in Ballacolla

In what a judge deemed an ‘exceptional’ case, the family of a man who died while helping out neighbours on a farm in Ballacolla wrote to the DPP asking that their neighbours not be prosecuted over his death.

​71 year-old Michael ‘Mick’ Byrne from Ballacolla, tragically died after he fell through a void in the roof of a shed at the farm of father and son Seamus and Patrick McEvoy at Coolderry, Ballacolla, on October 9, 2023.

Seamus (64) and his son Patrick McEvoy entered guilty pleas to charges under health and safety legislation at Portlaoise Circuit Court earlier this month. Seamus and Patrick both pled guilty to three charges including failing to ensure a place of work was safe and without risk to health resulting in the fatal injuries, failing to appoint a project supervisor and failure to put a plan in place for working at height. Patrick admitted one further charge of failing to ensure a workspace did not have a gap large enough for an employee to fall through.

At their sentencing on Thursday, November 12, a victim impact statement was read by Michael Byrne’s son Alan on behalf of his wife Linda and his adult children Eoin, Danny and Shane at a sitting of Portlaoise Circuit Court.

“We want to make clear that we recognise this tragedy has affected two families. While we have lost a husband, father, brother and grandfather, we also recognise that the McEvoy family have had to live with the consequences of this terrible accident. We appreciate that this has undoubtedly been an extremely difficult and distressing experience for them also.

“As a family, we do not hold the McEvoy family personally accountable for Michael’s death. We understand the circumstances in which Michael was there that day and have never believed that anyone deliberately intended for harm to come to him. We have no wish to see another family experience further hardship or distress as a consequence of what has happened.”

Mr Byrne said the family fully understand and respect that the HSA has statutory responsibilities to investigate farm accidents and they recognised it was not simply an issue for their family.

“We previously made our views known to the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions, explaining that we did not wish to see a prosecution pursued. We did so after careful consideration of the circumstances and because of our genuine concern about the impact that a prosecution could have on the McEvoy family.

“Although we acknowledge and respect the decision that has been made, our position and our feelings towards the McEvoy family have not changed. We do not make this statement to diminish the seriousness of what happened or the fact that a life was lost. Nothing can change the loss we have suffered, and we understand that the court must consider the circumstances of the case and its wider responsibilities,” he stated.

The family asked that the sentencing judge would take their views into account when reaching his verdict.

“We hope that compassion and leniency will be shown to the McEvoy family when the court considers the appropriate outcome.

“Our family has never sought retribution. We recognise that this has been a deeply distressing experience for everyone involved, and we would like to see the matter brought to a conclusion with consideration and compassion for both families.

We hope that, in considering this case, the court will understand that our family does not wish to see further suffering arise from an already devastating tragedy,” they stated.

Judge Jonathan Dunphy thanked Mr Byrne for reading the statement and said “I will take all that you have said on board.”

The court had been told that the McEvoys had been carrying out work on the 86 acre farm jointly operated by Seamus and Patrick but primarily run by Seamus. They had secured a grant to install a robot milking parlour and they were in the process of carrying out that work.

Micheal was their neighbour and friend and he had over 50 years of experience in farm construction. He was assisting with the work as a friend and wasn’t employed or being paid for the work when the accident occurred.

The accident occurred at around 2.50pm and the court was told Patrick McEvoy, who was working on a separate part of the roof, observed Mr Byrne falling through the void in the roof.

The court was told he fell 6.4 metres through a gap in the roof and was rushed to hospital by air ambulance but was sadly pronounced dead in the Mater Hospital a short time later.

The cause of death was recorded as cranial and cerebral injuries secondary to a fall from a height.

When Health and Safety Authority (HSA) Inspector Aidan Kelly arrived at the farm the following day he discovered that there was no health and safety plan, no fall protection in the form of harness, net or hard hats.

Will Fennelly BL for the State said the application for the grant for the robotic parlour required the applicants to acknowledge their obligations under health and safety legislation when constructing the parlour. He said the robotic milking parlour was 90% complete with only the roof requiring completion.

Under questioning, Mr Kelly said both men had been fully honest and cooperative at all stages with the HSA investigation. They had also adhered to all of the HSA’s requests following the accident. The court was told the parlour was completed later in 2023.

Mr Fennelly said neither of the accused had any convictions and they were well respected in their community.

“They would be considered a very respectable and highly regarded family in the locality,” he said.

Colm Hennessy SC said “they were neighbours and knew each other very well and helping each other out was very normal and routine.” He said Patrick would have been the project manager on the job and Mr Byrne had been there two or three days in addition to the day of the accident.

He said Mr Byrne had years of experience and was a friendly neighbour who “was literally lending a hand to neighbours because he had literally 50 years of experience.” Mr Hennessy said there was no question that he was not an employee and it was acknowledged that he was doing the work out of neighbourlyness and generosity.

“Both men, they expressed their sorrow, deep sorrow at what had happened,” he said.

Mr Hennessy said his clients were fully cooperative, had no previous convictions and had entered guilty pleas at the earliest opportunity.

Mr Fennelly said the potential penalties for the offences was up to two years imprisonment and or a fine of up to €3,000,000. He said there were also costs of €4,196 for the DPP and €2,152.50 for the HSA.

Mr Hennessy said the McEvoy farm had been in the family for generations. He said it had been a suckler farm but they made a decision to get into dairy. Patrick had attended the University of Limerick and studied engineering and had a full time job off the farm as well as working on the farm and was also heavily involved in the GAA.

Mr Hennessy produced a reference from IFA President Francie Gorman who said the father and son are held “in the highest regard” particularly in the farming community. Mr Gorman described them as hardworking and respectable and said “they are part of the fabric of the community”.

Mr Hennessy asked Judge Dunphy to take the exceptional circumstances of the case into consideration. He said a large fine could result in them losing their family farm.

“Mr Byrne was there as a good gesture and a friendly neighbour lending a hand,” he said. He told Judge Dunphy that it wasn’t a commercial profit making job on a tight timeline where people were cutting corners.

“Patrick McEvoy had the skill and the confidence and knowledge to design and plan this building himself,” he said.

“There was certainly some degree of complacency,” he acknowledged.

Mr Hennessy asked the judge to deem it “passive neglect” as opposed to a deliberate disregard for health and safety. He suggested that with their combined experience the father and son were “maybe blinded in that confidence to safety measures that should have been in place”.

Mr Hennessy said “no steps were taken in any shape or form to try and play this down,” he added.

Referring to the “powerful” victim impact statement, he said, “the sheer decency and generosity of the Byrne family is extraordinary. It really speaks to the character of the people.”

“They are very good neighbours to each other and in the community they were very much a part of each other’s lives,” said Mr Hennessy.

Judge Dunphy offered his sympathy to the Byrne family and said it was clear that Michael Byrne was loved by many.

“It is clear to me that Mr Byrne would be immensely proud of the way his family were dealing with the case,” he remarked.

However, “I am very mindful of that but the court cannot lose sight of the fact this was a site with zero measures in place.”

He said the sentence had to act as a deterrent and he said if he were to exercise undue leniency the DPP would likely take issue and the matter could be returned to court.

He noted the two accused had “behaved impeccably” and “ticked every box” in terms of mitigation.

“Both men play an integral part in their community and are highly regarded,” Judge Dunphy noted.

He said their confidence and years of experience had resulted in a “blindness in their own abilities” and he acknowledged they were not “arm chair generals” directing employees into dangerous work spaces.

He said the offence in his view should attract a fine of €175,000 each but he took into account the mitigation and the views of the Byrne family.

“They contribute to their community and are clearly valued by their neighbours and friends and the wider community,” said Judge Dunphy.

“I am of the view that this is an exceptional case,” said Judge Dunphy as he reduced the fine to €50,000 on each of the men for the charge of “failure to ensure that a place of work was safe and without risk to health resulting the fatal injuries” and he ordered that they pay DPP and HSA costs. The remainder of the charges were taken into consideration. Mr Hennessy said the DPP and HSA costs had already been paid.

The Leinster Express had sight of the letter which was sent to the DPP by Linda Byrne on behalf of her family. They expressed their wish to formally express their views on the proposed charges in this case.

“Having considered the charges being proposed, we do not agree with the nature and extent of the charges being pursued. In our view, they are excessive and do not adequately reflect the circumstances or the scale of the project involved.

“We fully appreciate that health and safety legislation places obligations on those undertaking construction work and those responsible for farm safety. We understand that these obligations exist to protect people and that the law must be applied.

However, we believe it is important to distinguish between a large commercial construction project and the circumstances of this particular case. The works involved a relatively small-scale farm building project on a private farm. It was not a major construction development or a large commercial building site involving complex construction arrangements,” the family wrote.

“We wish to make clear that we do not agree with the proposed charges in their current form and would ask that our views be taken into consideration,” they said.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice