Pair accused of Portlaoise Patrick’s Day violence


A judge refused jurisdiction after watching Laois Garda CCTV footage
A judge refused jurisdiction in relation to a case of two men who are accused of violent disorder in Portlaoise on St Patrick’s Day in 2023.
Michael Nevin (22) of 5 Greenview, Mountmellick Road, Portlaoise, is accused of assault, engaging in threatening and abusive behaviour, violent disorder, criminal damage and it is alleged he picked up glasses which he threw towards staff at Maggie Mays pub in Portlaoise on St Patrick’s Day in 2023.
Christopher Nevin (28) also of 5 Greenview, Mountmellick Road, Portlaoise, is also accused of assault, violent disorder and engaging in threatening and abusive behaviour at Maggie May’s pub in Portlaoise on the same date.
Garda street view CCTV footage of the incident was played at a sitting of Portlaoise District Court as Judge Andrew Gubbins was asked to consider jurisdiction to decide whether the case should remain in the district court or go to a higher court.
The footage showed a man who appeared to be in an agitated state throwing glasses in the direction of the public house.
“Having viewed that I am going to refuse jurisdiction in relation to Michael Nevin,” said Judge Gubbins.
“I imagine for the purpose of administration I will refuse jurisdiction in relation to Christopher Nevin also,” he remarked.
The court was told there was no footage available from inside the public house where some of the incidents allegedly occurred.
Solicitor Brian Duffy asked why a summons wasn’t served on his client Christopher Nevin until recently despite the incident occurring over three years ago.
A Garda said that when they arrived to arrest Mr Nevin they were told he was no longer living at the address and had moved to the UK.
“Whoever was present said he had gone to England,” the garda said.
However, Mr Duffy said his client had been at the address the whole time.
The garda said that when gardaí went to serve the summons on him he wasn’t at the property.
Mr Duffy said his client had been available the whole time and he requested a strike out. He said his client could be prejudiced in relation to the taking of detailed instructions in light of the passage of time.
Judge Gubbins said “there is CCTV footage that can be viewed by your client” and it was now a matter for the trial judge. He adjourned the case back to Portlaoise District Court on January 11 for service of the book of evidence.
