'Shocking money' cost of selling cattle causing 'carnage' - Laois TD


Portlaoise-based TD has wants change in VAT rate addressed
Farmers are paying ‘shocking money’ to sell cattle in parts due to a tax change according to Laois TD Willie Aird who has also lamented the closure of marts around Laois.
The Portlaoise Fine Gael TD spoke in the Dáil, where TDs and Senators called for the flat-rate addition to VAT to be amended to ensure that farmers selling livestock through marts are not disadvantaged.
“It is not easy for marts at the moment. When I was a young fella, I was brought up in a farm in County Laois. We always had marts in Rathdowney, Portlaoise and Mountrath. Rathdowney was the first to go, then Portlaoise and finally Mountrath. We are left now with Ballinakill. A mart is important to the farming community. It is where people can meet maybe once a week or once a month. It is where they chat. They used to go for a pint, but that day is gone.
“Now, they go into the canteen and have a cup of tea or whatever, and that may be their social outlet for the week. Especially in the night marts we have in this country, everybody gathers together, and it is a night out for them. That is really what it is,
He spoke of the impact of a change to a VAT rate
“It is a huge challenge when somebody comes along and decides to drop the VAT rate from 5.1% to 4.5%. That has consequences on the price the farmer is paying to sell the animal. That is the first thing people look at on the docket when they come out after selling.
“The single comment people make when they come out is that the cost has gone up to €25 to sell one, it is shocking money and - I thought I would never hear someone saying it - all that the marts are doing is acting as collectors of farmers' money to give to the Revenue Commissioners,” he said.
He said he wants the Revenue Commissioners or the Department of Agriculture to explain how a figure is set or who in the Department set it.
“The people who brought this measure in did not realise the carnage they would cause. Stand up, everybody and be counted. That is why the marts are not getting throughput. I know it, especially from the number of people who were selling calves privately from farm to farm this year. That is also being encouraged by the co-operative system,” he said.
He said change must be made to an “absolutely wrong” situation. Dep Aird also lamented another change.
“The other thing that has gone completely is the luck money, and that is a pity. When I was a young fellow at the mart, getting the luck money was as important as paying for the animal,” he said.
